Court of Appeals Issues Significant Ruling

Friday, November 07, 2003
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals recently issued a significant ruling benefiting ship mortgagees and other maritime creditors with decisions in two related cases stemming from the bankruptcy of Commodore Cruise Lines (“Commodore”). In one case, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans ruled that AmWest Surety Ins. Co. ("AmWest") and other sureties who provided the $15 million bond required by the FMC for cruise operators calling at U.S. ports to secure refunds for passengers (an "FMC Bond"), had no lien on the Commodore Ships, and also ruled that Harris Trust & Savings Bank ("Harris Bank") which provided credit card services to Commodore under a merchant services agreement (and which provided refunds to passengers), also did not have a lien. If AmWest and Harris were to succeed on their claims, they would have had priority over not only the ships' mortgagee banks in collecting the proceeds from the auctions of the Commodore vessels, but would also have greatly diminished, if not eliminated, recoveries by holders of traditional maritime lien claims. Concerning AmWest, the Fifth Circuit ruled that despite the fact that the law requires an FMC Bond for a cruise line to operate, the Bond was not a maritime contract, and that the Bond was not a "necessary" giving rise to a lien. The court also rejected the sureties’ alternative argument that they were subrogated to the claims of the passengers. Passengers do not have liens for refunds when a cruise vessel does not sail. Similarly, the Fifth Circuit found that Harris’ generic credit card merchant services agreement was not a maritime contract and that the credit card processing services provided by Harris were not “necessaries” giving rise to a maritime lien. Bruce G. Paulsen of Seward & Kissel LLP represented the mortgagee EffJohn International Cruise Holdings, Inc. in both cases.

Maritime Today


The Maritime Industry's original and most viewed E-News Service

Maritime Reporter July 2016 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Legal

IOC Mulls Buying GSPC's Stake in Mundra Terminal

Indian Oil Corporation (IOC), the country's largest oil company,  is in talks to buy debt-laden Gujarat State Petroleum Corp’s (GSPC) stake in the under-construction Rs.

Ecuador Pays $112 mln Award to Chevron

Ecuador has paid $112 million to energy company Chevron Corp over a four-decade-old contract dispute, even though it remains in disagreement, the head of the central bank has said.

ASEAN in Discord Ahead of Meeting with top China, U.S. Diplomats

Southeast Asian nations were thrown into disarray after Cambodia on Saturday blocked them from issuing a statement referring to an international court ruling against

Maritime Security

Hyundai Bags NZ Defence Order

Hyundai Heavy Industries (HHI), the world’s largest shipbuilder, has won an order to build a 23,000 ton class logistics support vessel for New Zealand Defence

N.Korea Builds New Submarine Base

North Korea is in the midst of building a new naval base on the east coast to accommodate submarines capable of firing submarine-launched ballistic missiles (SLBMs), says IHS Jane's Defence Weekly.

Jakarta to Boost Security of Small Vessels

Jakarta will boost security of small vessels after hijackings 15 July, says a report in Protection Vessels International Ltd (PVI).   Indonesia is currently

 
 
Maritime Security Maritime Standards Navigation Offshore Oil Pipelines Pod Propulsion Port Authority Ship Electronics Ship Simulators Sonar
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.0545 sec (18 req/sec)