Huntington Risks Losing $194 Million on Carrier’s Overrun

Thursday, April 05, 2012

Huntington Ingalls Industries Inc. stands to loss as much as $194.3 million, more than 40 percent of its potential fee, under the Navy’s latest estimate of overruns for the USS Gerald R. Ford aircraft carrier, according to Bloomberg.

Construction of the Ford, the Navy’s most expensive warship, is likely to exceed by $884 million the shipbuilder’s target contract cost of about $5.2 billion for detailed design and construction, according to Navy officials and the service’s Selected Acquisition Report, obtained after it was delivered to Congress on March 29.

The Ford is intended to be the first in a $40 billion, three-ship class of carriers. Its rising costs have brought questions from Republican Senator John McCain about the Navy program and the shipbuilder’s performance. McCain of Arizona, a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, has asked the Government Accountability Office for a review.

Huntington’s performance on costs “has stabilized, but has a long way to go to turn it around,” said Sean Stackley, the Navy’s assistant secretary for acquisition. The company and Navy aren’t in agreement on what the carrier’s final construction cost will be, he said.

Under the carrier contract, the Navy would pick up $689.7 million of the overrun now projected as “most likely,” with the remaining $194.3 million subtracted from potential maximum construction fees of $467 million for Huntington Ingalls of Newport News, Virginia. The carrier is about 40 percent complete.

The company would earn 50 cents of every dollar it shaves from the $884 million projection, Stackley said. If costs rise still further, “they are at a point in the contract where they share 50/50,” he said.

“We continue to see improvements in our performance on the carrier,” Huntington Ingalls spokeswoman Beci Brenton said. “Although this is a ‘first-in-class’ ship with unique challenges, we anticipate that we will increase efficiencies and continue to retire risk in the three years remaining until delivery.”

The Ford’s total projected cost has increased 18 percent in four years to $12.3 billion, from $10.4 billion, according to Navy budget figures cited by the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service. That includes systems which won’t be provided by Huntington Ingalls, such as the nuclear reactor to power the ship, a dual-band radar from Raytheon Co., and an electromagnetic aircraft-launching system from General Atomics of San Diego.

The Navy already has taken action against the shipbuilder. Last year, it didn’t let the company bill $75 million in fees because of the overrun projections, and that money has been forfeited, Stackley said.

Other cost-control initiatives include designating a Huntington senior vice president and a superintendent to oversee costs, specifying labor-cost targets and intensely reviewing specifications for the vessel, according to the Navy.

The latest overrun estimate stems from “material cost growth, labor inefficiencies” and increases in one-time engineering costs, according to the Navy document.

The labor “inefficiencies are the result of ‘first of class’ challenges,” including production issues, such as the use of thin-plate steel and weld distortion, the Navy wrote.

Huntington Ingalls “has had 10 consecutive months of improvements in meeting cost targets,” Rear Admiral Tom Moore, the Navy’s program executive officer for carriers, said in an interview.

“If they continue the trend they are on, I’m comfortable we will come in under the ’most likely’ $884 million estimate,” he said.

Still, he said, the company won’t meet the original targets.

On labor, the company is moving closer to the goal of 40 million man-hours on the carrier, from an earlier estimate of 53 million, Moore said. A man-hour is the work one person does in an hour.

“I need to drive them down further,” he said.

The company would receive the minimum fee allowed, about $196 million, if its performance deteriorates and the construction exceeds a worst-case overrun of $1.1 billion by completion in mid-2015, according to Stackley, who called that an unlikely outcome.

The minimum covers “a couple percent of profit and allowable costs,” he said.

The Navy disclosed in February that it was adding $811 million to the Ford’s budget through 2017 to cover increases, including $273 million directly tied to the construction overrun (Bloomberg).


 

Maritime Reporter September 2014 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Contracts

Wärtsilä, Diesel United Renew Pact

Wärtsilä and Diesel United Ltd in Japan have signed a ten-year renewal of their co-operation agreement for the sale, manufacturing and servicing of Wärtsilä low-speed marine engines.

Delta "T" Hooks for Offshore Customer

Gaining further ground into the offshore crane market, Delta "T" Systems supplied Cranston Eagle hooks to crane manufacturer Appleton Marine, Inc.   These cranes

China to Import 335 MT of Naphtha, Wants More

China is set to import more than 335,000 tonnes of naphtha and diesel, rare moves for the world's no. 2 oil consumer given it has been self-sufficient at meeting domestic oil product demand,

Shipbuilding

Equinox Class Scrubber Systems Receive Certification

Algoma Central Corporation (“Algoma”), the largest Canadian shipowner and operator of domestic Great Lakes vessels announces that it has received all requisite

Arctic Oil: Bourbon to Enter Arctic Market in 2016

Bourbon plans to enter the growing Arctic Offshore market in 2016 with a new Anchor Handling Tug Supply (AHTS) vessel built by the Vard shipyard. This AHTS (Anchor

Mitsubishi Exits Cruise Business; Books $357m Loss

Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd. (MHI) announced its decision to book an extraordinary loss from its cruise ship business in the company's consolidated financial

Navy

Italy Ending Med Sea Rescues

Rights groups warn of risk of more deaths; EU mission Triton will have more limited scope. Italy said on Friday it would close a sea rescue mission that has saved the lives of more than 100,

Libyan Government: Ports, Oil Fields Safe

Libyan oil ports and fields are safe and under government control, the country's interior minister said on Friday after visting the eastern Brega port. "This

Keel Laid, Fabrication Started on 2 Navy Warships

This week, General Dynamics Bath Iron Works celebrated two milestone events for the Arleigh Burke-class program. On October 30, Bath Iron Works held a keel laying

 
 
Maritime Contracts Naval Architecture Offshore Oil Pod Propulsion Port Authority Ship Electronics Ship Repair Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction Sonar
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1802 sec (6 req/sec)