5 ‘Gotchas’ of Marine Insurance

By Randall Carnahan
Monday, August 20, 2012

“Gotchas” are pitfalls, catches, bait and land mines – a kicker, snare or snag. They are surprises and, in the world of insurance, surprises are rarely a good thing.

 

‘Gotchas’ can be caused by different things. It may be the age of the coverage forms; it may be case law has moved on beyond the policy’s intent. Or, it may be there is a ‘disconnect’ between policy wording and current business practices.


Sometimes, these things occur simply because some insurance contracts are impenetrable.  Insurance policies are a distinctly difficult set of documents to understand. In the world of policy language, I have always found Ocean Marine insurance forms to be more entertaining than the general class. Enlivened by terms like “Assailing Thieves” and “Barratry”, they still have a bit of salt and you can almost imagine Jack Aubrey clomping about the quarterdeck. 
 

Even the Marine forms, however, can make your eyes roll back in your head. Crafted to be precise, they are sometimes so dense they end up in some cases being unreadable. The precision and clarity originally intended by its authors instead results in just the opposite. 
 

And sometimes, it is just the nature of the beast. The freedom we enjoy in Marine insurance to manuscript forms, for each Company to create its own forms – this freedom creates complexity and ‘Gotchas’ can result. 
Whatever the reason, ‘Gotchas,’ large and small, do exist. While Risk Managers, their Brokers and Average Adjustors that live in the Marine insurance world may know about them, it may be that the typical Business owner – or even their Agent if they are not specialists – will be unaware of them.

 

Garden Variety Gotchas
For example, one of my favorite Gotchas is in the A.I. Builders Risk form. A standard activity of Boat Builders, of course, is to sea trial their boats. And, in the course of the trials, they will need to man the vessel. A Boat Builder may be excused if they believe that, having bought the requisite Builders Risk insurance policy, the exposures customary to the trade will have been addressed – including Crew. The Builders Risk coverage forms do cover the sea trials, but liability for injury or death of employees is excluded. The form should be re-titled “Builders Risk Form Without Crew Coverage”. Now, we’re all on the same page.
 

The Brown Water forms have their share of ‘Gotchas,’ as well.  The Institute Tug Form, for example, contains the Watchman Clause, which reads:

 

WATCHMAN
It is agreed that when this Vessel is tied up or moored, it shall be at all times in charge of a watchman in the employ of the Assured, whose duty it shall be to make careful examination of the Vessel throughout at reasonable intervals, including inspection of the bilges.

 

This is a case where the coverage form has been passed by business practice and technology.  Watchmen have been replaced in many cases by inexpensive monitoring devices that have bilge alarms, low battery alerts, GPS tracking and infrared motion detectors - and will send you a text message alert if anyone of them is triggered. Yet, the Watchman Clause is there on lines 141-142 of the Tug form and violation of its terms may void coverage. Now, many Owners may stage their equipment at different facilities such as ABC Shipyard – and they have Watchmen.  However, the clause stipulates a Watchman “in the employ of the Assured.”  If we are paying wharfage to the Yard, are they and their Watchmen in our employ?
 

Another coverage conundrum is presented when trying to marry the standard Towboat Hull forms with the standard Protection & Indemnity (P&I) forms. The Taylor and Institute Tug Form excludes claims for loss of life and personal injury, and the P&I forms – where loss of life coverage is found, exclude “claims arising out of or having relation to the towage of any other vessel or craft.” Knitting these coverages together to properly insure the Tower’s exposures can be a challenge for the uninitiated.
 

A fourth Gotcha resides in the Equipment Floaters carried by Marine Contractors, among others. Floaters are meant to cover our Equipment and Tools that move from site to site and barge to barge as needed and are as close to providing “All Risk” coverage as we are going to get these days. Covered Equipment can range from employee’s hand tools to $800,000 crawler cranes working off a deck barge. So, you can imagine the surprise when the policy contains an exclusion for Waterborne Equipment.
 

Our fifth ‘Gotcha’ relates to fiberglass production boat builders. Builders will buy Property and Business Interruption insurance to protect their assets.  And they may well insure their Boat Molds on the same premise. Indeed it can be argued that the Molds are the more valuable asset in terms of revenue stream. Buildings are relatively easy to replace in the current market.  Molds, though, are crafted to very close tolerances, and for each production line or model there will be multiple molds to be replaced for the hull, deck, hatches and rudders.  It is common to insure the Molds under the Marine policy with its more flexible terms of coverage.  The ‘Gotcha’ is that the Business Interruption coverage on the Property policy will not extend to the Molds insured on the Marine policy.

 

Gotcha Fix
Each of these ‘Gotchas’ have policy solutions. Endorsements added, clauses deleted, a word or two crossed out; all of which unfortunately increases the policy’s complexity. But the larger solution may just be one of education and information. By shining a light on these aspects of Marine insurance, they move from “Gotcha” status to the known, and then can be dealt with. Rely on experienced Marine insurance brokers: a Marine specialist will identify the Gotchas in the standard coverage forms and discuss with you how they will be addressed. They will then work with underwriters to craft a policy that roots out the ‘Gotchas’ and provide coverage that fits your business needs.


In the meantime, are there other ‘Gotchas’ out there? You bet. These five examples are by no means the only ‘Gotchas’ lurking out there. Perhaps you have been bitten by one or know someone that was. If you would like to share your experience please let me know. We can start cataloguing them, make them available and shine a light on them. 
 

+ (Published in the August 2012 edition of MarineNews - www.marinelink.com) +

 

Randy Carnahan is Gencorp’s Marine Director and specializes in placement of Vessel, Shiprepair and Marine Contracting risks. He began his career as a Claims Adjuster which taught him the value of a well-crafted policy. Reach him at: rcarnahan@gencorp-ins.com

 

Maritime Today


The Maritime Industry's original and most viewed E-News Service

Maritime Reporter January 2016 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Contracts

Australia Submarines: Japan Vs France

While Japan is confident it has proven itself the best contender to build Australia's new submarines, the French have moved to undermine Japan’s bid to build the navy’s new submarines.

Novoship to Install Ecochlor BWTS on 4 Tankers

SCF Novoship Technical Management has selected the Ecochlor Ballast Water Treatment System (BWTS) to be retrofitted on three Aframax Oil Tankers and one Product Carrier.

Optimarin Breaks into the Fishing Market

Ballast water treatment (BWT) specialist Optimarin has landed its first ever contract in the fishing segment. The Norwegian firm will now supply its soon to be

Shipbuilding

Australia Submarines: Japan Vs France

While Japan is confident it has proven itself the best contender to build Australia's new submarines, the French have moved to undermine Japan’s bid to build the navy’s new submarines.

Elbit Systems Introduces Seagull

Israel’s Elbit Systems unveiled a prototype of what it claims is the world’s first unmanned system for anti-submarine warfare (ASW) missions.   Developed in less

Edison Chouest Opening Mississippi Shipyard

Edison Chouest Offshore locating shipbuilding operations, TopShip, LLC, in Gulfport, Miss.   Gov. Phil Bryant and officials from Edison Chouest Offshore, an offshore

Ship Repair & Conversion

Novoship to Install Ecochlor BWTS on 4 Tankers

SCF Novoship Technical Management has selected the Ecochlor Ballast Water Treatment System (BWTS) to be retrofitted on three Aframax Oil Tankers and one Product Carrier.

Seaspan Venture: Like for Like

“We don’t usually remove the heads at mid-life on the Cummins engines,” Randy Beckler, Shore Engineer for Seaspan Marine, explained in reference to the 2003 launched

Demolition Age Drops as the Dry Bulk Market Enters Another Challenging Year

The dry bulk market faced a lot of headwind in 2015 as dwindling demand and over-supply created very unfavourable market conditions, says BIMCO.   2016 has shown

Casualties

US Warship Rescues Mariners in Distress

Nimitz-class aircraft carrier USS Dwight D. Eisenhower (CVN 69) (Ike) came to the rescue of distressed mariners at sea, February 7.   Ike received a distress

Three Dead on Pemex Platform, Fire Under Control

Three workers were killed and at least seven injured when a fire broke out on a Pemex oil processing platform in the Gulf of Mexico, but the latest in a string of incidents is now under control,

Anthem of the Seas to Port after Rough Night

Multiple media outlets including CBS News report that Royal Caribbean's new cruise ship Anthem of the Seas was hit by a strong strom, reportedly resulting in no

Insurance

Three Dead on Pemex Platform, Fire Under Control

Three workers were killed and at least seven injured when a fire broke out on a Pemex oil processing platform in the Gulf of Mexico, but the latest in a string of incidents is now under control,

Glencore to Lift Iranian Fuel Oil at Bandar Mahshahr

Anglo-Swiss commodity trader Glencore has chartered a ship to load Iranian fuel oil at the Iranian port of Bandar Mahshahr in a move that signals the return of

Norbulk Selects Parker Kittiwake’s Cat Fines Test Kit

Parker Kittiwake, a leading global supplier of asset control and protection technology, has today announced a significant order of its recently launched Cat Fines

P&I Clubs

Glencore to Lift Iranian Fuel Oil at Bandar Mahshahr

Anglo-Swiss commodity trader Glencore has chartered a ship to load Iranian fuel oil at the Iranian port of Bandar Mahshahr in a move that signals the return of

Boxship Aground Near Port of Hamburg

A Chinese container ship that is one of the world's largest has run aground on the river Elbe near Germany's largest port Hamburg but shipping to the harbour continues as normal,

Distressed Freighter Could Ground if Salvage Fails

A stricken cargo ship drifting on its side off the French Atlantic coast will run aground in southwest France if a renewed attempt to tow it to port fails on Monday, a French maritime official said.

 
 
Maritime Contracts Maritime Security Naval Architecture Navigation Pipelines Pod Propulsion Port Authority Ship Electronics Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1539 sec (6 req/sec)