USCG Lessons Learned: Proper Maintenance

Thursday, July 22, 2010

A partial propulsion failure occurring on a commercial vessel can result in significant injury and damage when the movement of the vessel is unchecked and an allision or collision occurs.  In some circumstances a significant amount of hull damage can occur at very slow speeds, while in others, multiple fatalities may occur. Owners and operators, and those responsible for vessel maintenance, specifically steerage and propulsion systems may find the following information useful and recognize the need to examine their own vessel's equipment and maintenance systems.  Although the following speaks to a specific propulsion system, the noted lessons are useful for any type.

The vessel was equipped with cycloidal drive units fore and aft.  The propulsion units provide thrust forward, backwards, athwartship directions, or an infinite number of combinations. The control of the unit is achieved by two hydraulic rams actuated by control oil delivered from electro-hydraulic solenoid operated spool valves.  Control oil for operation is piped from a branch of the main lube oil supply to the propulsion unit and flows through one of two canister type oil filters. From the filter, the oil proceeds to two, three position spool valves. An electrical signal positions the valves, thus controlling the flow to the respective hydraulic rams; therefore regulating the output of the propulsion unit. Two other electro-hydraulic valves are also in the circuitry complementing the operation.

Investigators discovered that several of the spool valves failed to operate as designed, were sluggish and stuck in various positions. Lube oil samples were taken from the filter housings and appeared highly contaminated.
Investigators learned that no replacement filters or spare valves were available onboard or in stock at the nearby maintenance facility.  The operator had previously purchased a complete control assembly consisting of new electro-hydraulic valves and filter housings which was on hand in storage. This system was installed post casualty and once replaced, the system worked as designed and required only minor adjustment.

The vessel was operated, maintained and managed by multiple levels of engineering personnel both onboard and ashore serving operational and support roles. Over the years, many of those engineers interacted with the system. However, despite their experience with the system they failed to recognize that the canister filters required routine replacement and that poor oil quality could contribute to improper operation of the solenoid valves.  Further, no one identified that the Safety Management System and vessel Maintenance Management systems failed to provide a line item for the lube oil filters despite a requirement for routine changing in the associated equipment manual.

As a result of this casualty, the Coast Guard strongly encourages vessel owners and operators, engineers, and support staffs to perform a "preventative maintenance gap analysis" by:

1) closely inspecting their equipment, systems, and components, and reviewing associated technical manuals to ensure that all items requiring maintenance are captured in their respective maintenance management systems and;

2) ensuring that the maintenance is actually performed.

This document is provided for informational purposes only and does not relieve any domestic or international safety, operational or material requirement. Developed by the Headquarters Office of Investigations and Analysis. Questions can be addressed to Mr. Ken Olsen, Kenneth.W.Olsen@uscg.mil.

Maritime Reporter June 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Coast Guard

Cargoship Disabled and Grounded in Dardanelles

General cargo vessel Ibrahim Konan  (7,618 dwt, built 2008) today (July 1) suffered rudder failure and ran aground in Dardanelles in front of Eceabat in Turkey,

Coast Guard Monitoring Rocket Debris off US

The U.S. Coast Guard informs it is working with SpaceX and partner agencies to monitor the debris field of the exploded Falcon 9 rocket in the Atlantic Ocean more

Shell Rig Departs for Arctic Despite Protest

U.S. Coast Guard and police boats cleared a way through protesters in kayaks at a Seattle-area port on Tuesday so a drilling ship could head for the Arctic on behalf of Royal Dutch Shell.

Maritime Safety

Fincantieri, Finmeccanica Win Italian Navy LHD Contract

Fincantieri, one of the world’s largest shipbuilding groups and reference player in the naval shipbuilding industry, and Finmeccanica, Italy’s leading manufacturer in the high technology sector,

USN Data Center Hit by Electrical Storm

An electrical storm that hit the evening of June 27 affected the data center at Navy Personnel Command (NPC) and BUPERS On-Line (BOL) was offline until 3 p.

SUNY Maritime to Host e-Navigation Conference

The e-Navigation Underway 2015 – North America conference will be hosted by The State University of New York (SUNY) Maritime College from September 28 to 30 on the college’s Throggs Neck, N.

 
 
Maritime Contracts Maritime Security Maritime Standards Naval Architecture Navigation Pipelines Pod Propulsion Ship Electronics Sonar Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1289 sec (8 req/sec)