DNV Calls for Better Safety Barrier Management

MarineLink.com
Thursday, May 09, 2013
Peter Bjerager

To avoid major accidents, safety barriers are critical to stop accident pathways before they become serious, and they need to be treated accordingly. This has to be reflected in operations and ideally in regulations. If not, safety barriers which often address rare events might lose the everyday battle for attention among all the safety and production systems in daily use, leaving a company with fictional barriers and false sense of security.

At the OTC session for safety and environmental management systems, a paper was presented by DNV’s Dr. Robin Pitblado and Dr. Peter Bjerager, called Offshore major accident safety: Is SEMS enough?.

The implementation of mandatory Safety and Environmental Management System (SEMS) certification for operator in the Gulf of Mexico was a necessary and natural regulatory move after the Macondo accident three years ago. Most oil majors and operators in the Gulf of Mexico were already implementing these systems, recognizing the value of a systematic approach to safety management.

But to achieve a step change in offshore safety, DNV argues that additional priority should be given to the performance of safety barriers, and what the operators do to ensure the barriers are reliable and meeting their expected performance.

The oil and gas industry in the Gulf of Mexico is already familiar with the use of safety barriers to prevent major accidents from happening, and to mitigate the consequences when they do occur. The approach is often illustrated by the bow-tie model. However, this approach is not always used to its full potential, and regulators and operators will benefit from zeroing in on the weakest link: “Barriers degrade over time if not looked after. Particularly the barriers designed to prevent a near miss incident from developing into a serious accident. This line of defense might be forgotten in day-to-day operations, losing the everyday battle for attention among all the safety and production systems in daily use. One example is equipment for emergency shutdown that is to be used only in emergencies, meaning it is difficult to test during operations and tests are infrequent” explains Robin Pitblado, DNV’s Director of SHE Risk Management.

“Ideally companies would have real-time status on each barrier to manage their activities safely. Some companies have developed procedures that specify for every planned activity what barriers must be functioning – this recognizes that barriers have holes and some may be degraded. But a challenge is to know which barriers are degraded. Inspection, preventive maintenance and audit are all good techniques, but have a cycle time that can leave a year or more between status updates,” he says.

Pragmatic and close to reality
To strike a balance between plans, regulations, safety theory and a healthy dose of reality checks, existing processes can be put to better use: Actual and near-miss incidents are routinely reported and investigated. Based on knowledge from major accident investigations and more routine incident investigations, DNV has developed a method to provide much more frequent updates on barrier status – the BSCAT investigation method.

Every incident means that some barriers have failed, and since many facilities experience over 100 actual or near-miss events annually, analyzing these for barrier failures can provide the most frequent and up-to-date status of barriers. It has the side benefit that the facility risk assessment is used for every incident, verifying that it is correct and reinforcing the importance of risk management to all staff.  It turns out this approach is not much more work than routine investigations. Since barrier performance is assessed this feeds very well the new requirements for process safety indicators.

Both the American Petroleum Institute (API) and the International Association of Oil and Gas Producers identify demands on barriers amongst the most useful leading safety indicators (e.g. API 754 and OGP 456), and many companies are committed to adopting these standards. “To DNV, this means that adopting this approach can be done pragmatically, and deliver the improvement in offshore safety that we should achieve related to major accidents,” concludes Peter Bjerager.

Dr. Peter Bjerager is Director of Operations for DNV Oil & Gas in North America.
Peter Bjerager has spent his professional career within safety and risk management of offshore, maritime and industrial enterprises and projects and has held a number of management positions in DNV in the U.S., Europe and Asia. Peter Bjerager has a M.Sc. and Ph.D. from the Technical University of Denmark and a Ph.D. in structural reliability at the same university. Before joining DNV, he held research positions at the Technical University of Denmark and Stanford University. He has published about 50 articles in scientific journals and conference proceedings.

Dr. Robin Pitblado is a Vice President working in Risk Management Solutions in Houston.
He is one of DNV's more senior and experienced safety management, safety case, risk assessment and accident investigation engineers. He is expert in safety and environment risk assessment technology, PSM assessment, consequence modeling, safety management system audits, and government compliance reviews. He has spent periods managing risk teams and offices in both the U.K. and the U.S. Dr. Pitblado has worked on professional assignments in the U.K., U.S., Europe, Australia, and the Far East for a variety of industrial, professional body, and government clients. He has published widely, including being lead or joint author / editor of four textbooks.

 

Maritime Reporter January 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Technology

‘Landmark Year’ for RS in 2014

For Russian Maritime Register of Shipping (RS), 2014 marked the 101st year of its activities. The classification society said 2014 also marked a landmark year,

Partnership Targets Waste Conversion Solutions

Terragon Environmental Technologies Inc. has entered into a strategic partnership with Green Marine Capital (GMC) in an effort to enable off grid sustainability

CakeBoxx, Globe Tracker Partner for Asset Tracking

Globe Tracker International, a company in global autonomous asset tracking, monitoring, remote management and data sharing services, and CakeBoxx Technologies,

News

NOIA: Draft Offshore Lease Program Both Hits and Misses

National Ocean Industries Association (NOIA) President Randall Luthi issued a statement on the 2017-2022 Draft Proposed OCS Oil and Gas Leasing Program, stating the U.

‘Landmark Year’ for RS in 2014

For Russian Maritime Register of Shipping (RS), 2014 marked the 101st year of its activities. The classification society said 2014 also marked a landmark year,

Maritime Safety

Northeast Winter Storm Disrupts Shipping

Winter Storm Juno, which has brought snow and gale force winds to the North East Coast of the United States, is causing severe disruption to shipping across the entire coastline.

Secure VGP Compliance with New Verification Service

Recent updates to the US Vessel General Permit (VGP) have brought new technical and reporting requirements for vessels operating in US waters, including the need

Oil Tankers are Front Line of Libya's Struggles

Crew members killed in tanker attack this month; West fears worsening violence could lead to civil war. Oil shippers face higher costs and the possible loss of insurance cover on Libyan voyages,

Vessels

CORIMA Orders a Damen ASD Tug 2810

CORIMA, part of the Italian Gesmar Group, has ordered a Damen ASD Tug 2810.   The Damen ASD Tug 2810, which has a 60 metric tons bollard pull, will be deployed in the port of Ancona.

GE Powers Diadema Cruise Ship

Fincantieri shipyard to equip in-board propulsion for Carnival and Costa vessels, GE’s Power Conversion business has helped the shipyard successfully deliver the

Carnival, China Merchants Sign MOU

MOU will explore both Port & Destination Development and Ship-Owning joint ventures with the goal of potentially launching China’s first world-class domestic cruise brand.

Classification Societies

‘Landmark Year’ for RS in 2014

For Russian Maritime Register of Shipping (RS), 2014 marked the 101st year of its activities. The classification society said 2014 also marked a landmark year,

Secure VGP Compliance with New Verification Service

Recent updates to the US Vessel General Permit (VGP) have brought new technical and reporting requirements for vessels operating in US waters, including the need

KR Launches Software to Aid ECA Compliance

The Korean Register (KR) has launched an in-house developed software program to assist vessels with fuel oil change over when complying with the new low sulphur regulations.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Contracts Naval Architecture Navigation Pod Propulsion Salvage Ship Electronics Ship Repair Sonar Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.5090 sec (2 req/sec)