State Aid to Saremar Ruled Illegal

MarineLink.com
Thursday, January 23, 2014

After an in-depth investigation, the European Commission has concluded that part of the support measures that Sardinia had granted to the maritime company Saremar in 2011 and 2012 was incompatible with EU state aid rules. In particular, a capital injection not approved on market conditions and the compensation for carrying out certain maritime services have provided an undue economic advantage to Saremar that its competitors did not have. Saremar needs to pay back this undue advantage of around €10.8 million in total, to remedy the distortion of competition this has created.

At the same time the Commission concluded that two letters of comfort issued by the Region did not guarantee any financial obligation of the company and did not therefore constitute State aid to Saremar. The Commission also concluded that the promotional activities carried out by Saremar were priced at market value.

Commission Vice President Joaquín Almunia, in charge of competition policy, said, "Member States and regional authorities are of course free to finance services of general economic interest. However, as foreseen by EU rules, this should be done in a transparent way, on the basis of clearly defined public service obligations."

In 2012 Saremar received capital injection from Sardinia for an announced amount of €6.1 million. The Commission concluded that no private investor operating under market conditions would have accepted to invest on these conditions in similar circumstances. The capital injection therefore constitutes state aid, as it conferred an economic advantage to Saremar as compared to its competitors, who have to operate without public money. Moreover, this state aid is incompatible with EU rules because it was not accompanied by the implementation of a restructuring plan fulfilling the requirements of the guidelines on state aid for the rescue and restructuring of companies in difficulty. The Commission has therefore ordered Italy to recover from Saremar the part of the capital injection already implemented.

Lastly, the Commission found that a €10 million compensation granted to Saremar for the operation in 2011 and 2012 of two maritime routes linking Sardinia to mainland Italy was not in line with EU rules on services of general economic interest (SGEI) (see IP/11/1571). These rules provide that public service providers can receive compensation for the net costs of the delivery of their public service obligations, where the parameters to calculate the compensation are established in advance and the public service obligations are clearly defined. However, when Saremar was entrusted with the operation of the two maritime routes, no compensation mechanism was set up for this activity. Moreover, the entrustment acts did not clearly define the public service obligations imposed on Saremar. The Commission therefore concluded that Saremar was not entitled to compensation and needed to pay back the sums it received.

Background

Saremar is one of the regional companies of the former Tirrenia Group. The company traditionally operated maritime services under a public service contract with the Italian State, in force until end 2008 but subsequently prolonged. In 2009, Saremar was transferred from Tirrenia to the Sardinian Region.

In October 2011 the Commission launched an in-depth investigation into public support measures in favor of companies of the former Tirrenia Group, namely Tirrenia di Navigazione, Caremar, Laziomar, Saremar, Siremar and Toremar (see IP/11/1157).

The Commission extended the scope of this investigation in November 2012 and amended it in December 2012, to take account of an additional aid measure notified by Italy.

Under the EU guidelines on rescue and restructuring aid, companies in difficulty may receive state aid under certain conditions. Such aid has a high potential of distorting competition in the EU internal market, as it artificially keeps companies alive that would have otherwise exited the market. Aid may be granted for a period of six months ("rescue aid"). Beyond this period, the aid must either be reimbursed or a restructuring plan must be notified to the Commission for the aid to be approved ("restructuring aid"). The plan must ensure that the long-term viability of a company is restored without further state support, that distortions of competition induced by the state support are addressed through compensatory measures and that the company contributes to the costs of restructuring. Finally, restructuring aid may be granted only once over a period of ten years ('one time, last time' principle).

The non-confidential version of the decision will be made available in the State Aid Register under the case numbers SA.32014, SA.32015 and SA.32016 (all concerning follow-on companies of the Tirrenia group) on the DG Competition website once any confidentiality issues have been resolved. New publications of state aid decisions on the internet and in the Official Journal are listed in the State Aid Weekly e-News.

europa.eu
 

Maritime Reporter March 2014 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

People & Company News

DP World in Talks With Banks for $3b Loan

Dubai-owned port operator DP World is in talks with lenders to triple the size of an existing $1 billion loan, as well as extend the lifespan and reduce the interest rate,

Webinar to Examine 3D Laser Scanning in the Marine Industry

3D laser scanning has taken much interest in the maritime industry as it continues to find greater acceptance in the sector. In an up-close look at 3D laser scanning,

Royal Caribbean Profits Take a Hit

Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd reported a much lower-than-expected quarterly profit as costs rose and passengers spent less onboard. Shares of the company, whose

Legal

Court: Japan's Mitsui Paid to Release Ship

China Supreme Court says Mitsui pays about $29 mln; Ship released about 0030 GMT Thursday. Ship was seized over dispute dating back to 1930s. Advisor to plaintiffs says will likely demand more money.

Lawyer: Korea Ferry Owners Accept Responsibilities

The family that has a major stake in companies that control the shipping operator whose ferry sank last week, likely to have killed hundreds, will take social and

Mitsui O.S.K. Ship Ready To Leave Chinese Port

Japanese shipping firm Mitsui O.S.K. Lines Ltd said on Thursday that its ship, the "Baosteel Emotion" 226,434 deadweight-tonne ore carrier, is ready to leave

Finance

Petroecuador Tenders to Buy High Octane Naphtha

State-run Petroecuador has launched two tenders to buy a total of 22 cargoes, 240,000 barrels each, of high octane naphtha RON 87 and 93 for delivery starting on May 21-23,

DP World in Talks With Banks for $3b Loan

Dubai-owned port operator DP World is in talks with lenders to triple the size of an existing $1 billion loan, as well as extend the lifespan and reduce the interest rate,

Norway's Oil Sector May Face More Project Cuts, Delays

More oil and gas projects in Norway could be put on hold because of rising costs, adding to a growing list of developments that have been delayed or called off,

News

Petroecuador Tenders to Buy High Octane Naphtha

State-run Petroecuador has launched two tenders to buy a total of 22 cargoes, 240,000 barrels each, of high octane naphtha RON 87 and 93 for delivery starting on May 21-23,

DP World in Talks With Banks for $3b Loan

Dubai-owned port operator DP World is in talks with lenders to triple the size of an existing $1 billion loan, as well as extend the lifespan and reduce the interest rate,

Norway's Oil Sector May Face More Project Cuts, Delays

More oil and gas projects in Norway could be put on hold because of rising costs, adding to a growing list of developments that have been delayed or called off,

Government Update

Court: Japan's Mitsui Paid to Release Ship

China Supreme Court says Mitsui pays about $29 mln; Ship released about 0030 GMT Thursday. Ship was seized over dispute dating back to 1930s. Advisor to plaintiffs says will likely demand more money.

Korean Ferry: Pair Drowned with PFD's Tied Together

A boy and girl trapped in a sinking South Korean ferry with hundreds of other high school students tied their life jacket cords together, a diver who recovered their bodies said,

GAO: Limited Commercial Arctic Development Foreseen

Decreasing seasonal sea ice has opened up Arctic waters for longer periods with resulting potential economic opportunities in commercial shipping, cruises, commercial fishing, oil, and mining.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Standards Naval Architecture Offshore Oil Pipelines Salvage Ship Repair Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1905 sec (5 req/sec)