Dial Subchapter ‘M’ for Money

By Richard Paine
Monday, September 23, 2013

CFR 46 Subchapter M is on track and heading for you.  Neither the U.S. Flag inland vessel industry, nor the United States Coast Guard knows for sure where or when, but it is coming. One thing is for sure, however, it is going to be expensive – very expensive.

Subchapter ‘M’ has been cooking for over a decade and is meant to address a segment of the U.S. commercial inland marine industry that currently carries the moniker of “uninspected” vessel. Far from truly uninspected, responsible operators, in consort with the Coast Guard, The American Waterways Operators (AWO), insurers, lenders and classification societies, have for many years – for safety and liabilities sake – addressed a considerable number of issues now scheduled to be codified under Subchapter M. Through Notices of Proposed Rulemaking, public comment periods, and industry input, the final version is due out—sometime soon. Your guess as to when is as good as anyone’s.
In the meantime, consider this: Industry statistics and various publications (including a September 2012 article in MarineNews) claim that the number vessels that will be subject to Subchapter M regulations could be in the range of 5,000 vessels. A highly respected and well accredited safety program developed over a decade ago by the AWO, the Responsible Carrier Program (RCP) has 241 current RCP-Certified and Provisional Operators.  While these 241 operators represent about 1600 self-inspected vessels, that number leaves a lot of vessels that may or may not be in compliance with the new regs.

Options for compliance include developing a Towing Safety Management System (TSMS) with scheduled periodic dry-docking/internal structural inspections and third party compliance audits or the more traditional approach of United States Coast Guard (USCG) inspections. The latter will still require annual and periodic inspections plus scheduled dry-docking with internal structural examinations. The former allows two years to develop a TSMS after the final rule is issued.
Passenger vessels have long been subject to inspections similar in many ways to the requirements proposed in Subchapter M. You can ask any passenger vessel operator whose vessel carries more than a six-pack how much fun it is: between the cost of developing safety management programs, attendant written documentation, periodic haulouts and inspections, requirements for onboard electrical and machinery systems, and other potentially huge expenses in maintaining a vessel’s Certificate of Inspection (COI), compliance is prohibitively expensive.
With the new proposed dry-docking intervals (based on area of operation) it may be difficult just to get dry-docked, inspected or repaired.  Competition for available services will be fierce—let alone costly. It is estimated that after the first two years of COI compliance, as much as 25% of the inland fleet will be up for dry-docking each year.  That number, plus the already existing dry-dock, inspection and repair demand, will make for interesting times.
The U.S. Maritime Administration (according to a 2011 Survey) insists that there are 117 active shipbuilders in 26 states. There are another 200 or so more businesses with the capability of building and repairing marine vessels. The study does not indicate what number of tugs, barges, passenger vessels; commercial fishing vessels, recreational vessels or other types are being built or repaired.  Furthermore, this study does not enumerate the number of facilities with dry docks, heavy lift cranes, travel lifts or other means to haul out large vessels.
With the increased requirement for periodic haulouts, possible sidetracking for hull and machinery repairs, probable lost revenue from downtime, some operators are left to wonder where the additional money to comply will come from. The obvious answer is from increased day-rates, but unless the increased rate complements an already established pool of maintenance and repair funds, increased rates are a cumulative fix to what might be an urgent and timely problem. Hence, and for the larger and more cash-flow positive operators, rising costs of increased maintenance, compliance, inspections and repairs might not present an immediate problem. But to the smaller operator, it could signal the death knell.

This industry was built largely on the backs of so-called “mom and pop” operations. The Gulf of Mexico is full of countless stories of how some of our industry’s largest operators got started. The generation that came out of the bayou to fight the good fight in Europe or Pacific theatres then came home to buy and operate the first of what might become a mighty fleet of boats. I know of operators in the Northeast whose great grandfathers rowed and sailed cargo across New England’s harbors, rough and tumble men who did not know how to quit. And, in the Pacific Northwest, many began their empires running steamboats carrying miners to the Alaska gold rush. And now, it is today’s smaller, start-up operators who are at greatest risk from the cost of compliance with Subchapter ‘M’. That said; there are some survival strategies that might make some sense:

  • Evaluate the amount of equity that you have accumulated in your vessels.  You might find that a significant amount of cash can be available for compliance by refinancing the existing mortgage on your vessels. If your loan is more than halfway through its life, given amortization of the principal, appreciation of the vessel’s value and other factors, as much as 40% to 50% of that value may be available to you as capital for compliance issues.
  • Reduce the size of your fleet. Determine what vessels are now in excess of your workload and monetize them. Cash at hand is often more valuable than a vessel with 75% utilization.
  • Utilize the benefits of membership in a recognized commercial marine association like the AWO or the Offshore Marine Services Association. Why reinvent the wheel if it’s already rolling?
  • Work early on with a competent professional that can help you develop your TSMS and engage a qualified, recognized third party auditor or utilize the USCG as your inspection “service.”
  • For shipbuilders and repairers who are preparing for the possible onslaught of compliance related work, contact a qualified commercial marine lender to buy a dry-dock. Loan packages can offer terms and amortization up to 15 years. If you are the recipient of a Maritime Administration small shipyard grant, contact a lender who will augment the grant amount with a term loan to help you acquire the equipment you need.


The “M” in Subchapter M arguably stands for money. There is no escaping that fact, but to survive the challenges the new regimen brings, be smart. Consult your financial professional, your accountant and your banker to see what options are available that can help ease the pain.


(As published in the September 2013 edition of Marine News - www.marinelink.com)

 

 

Maritime Today


The Maritime Industry's original and most viewed E-News Service

Maritime Reporter May 2016 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Shipbuilding

FIO’s New Research Vessel Enters Build Phase

The 78’ research vessel designed and engineered by Boksa Marine Design (BMD) in 2015 is headed to the building phase beginning in June.   BMD contracted with

HII Secures Aircraft Carrier Planning Contract

Huntington Ingalls Industries (HII) was awarded a $152 million contract for advance planning for the construction of the third aircraft carrier in the Gerald R.

Maritime Future Summit: Digital Shipping

Autonomous ships, smart on-board systems: At the Maritime Future Summit on September 5, industry leaders will discuss the future of shipping. For the first time

Finance

DP World Launches $1.2 bln Sukuk Issue to Cover Tender

Dubai-based ports operator DP World launched a seven-year $1.2 billion sukuk issue on Tuesday, a document from lead managers showed.   The issue, structured to

Baltic Index Falls on Weaker Demand

The Baltic Exchange's main sea freight index, tracking rates for ships carrying dry bulk commodities, fell on Tuesday as demand for larger vessel segments declined.

China Shipbuilding Plans Major Restructuring

State-owned China Shipbuilding Industry Corp (CSIC) is undertaking a major restructuring as it grapples with an industry downturn, and it will be the largest restructuring

Education/Training

Returning to the Scene of the Shipwrecks

A participant in a diving field school last fall, graduate student Tori Kiefer is back to help a new set of students learn the joy of surveying shipwrecks.   Last fall,

Crowley Awards Scholarships to Four Mass. Maritime Students

Four students from Massachusetts Maritime Academy (MMA) have been awarded Crowley Maritime Corp.’s Thomas B. Crowley Sr. Memorial Scholarships.   Chosen based on their academic achievement,

Automated Skill Erosion

The increasing automation of vessels is causing some mariners to lose basic maritime skills.   Cruise ship Royal Majesty Grounding During dinner on June 10, 1995,

Marine Equipment

Fail-proof System Access and Easy Operation

KVM redundancy concepts increase reliability of control room installations   German manufacturers G&D feel very much at home in especially safety-related control rooms.

Wood Group Bags Statoil MSA

Wood Group has been awarded an evergreen master services agreement (MSA) by Statoil to support the life cycles of its offshore  and onshore facilities. Work and

Korea Express Orders Two Quaymate M50 Cranes

Xiamen, People’s Republic of China, 24 May 2016 – Terex Port Solutions (TPS) notches up another success for its Terex Quaymate M50 mobile harbour crane. After the

Coast Guard

Grounded Bulker Repaired, Heads for Japan

The Captain of the Port for Oregon and southern Washington canceled the captain of the port order on the motor vessel Sparna allowing the vessel to leave its mooring at Kalama, Wash.

Towing Vessel Inspection Bureau Elects New Leaders

Towing Vessel Inspection Bureau Holds Annual Membership Meeting; Elects New Leadership and Votes to Proceed with a Third Party Organization Application to the Coast

Bulker Loses Propulsion off California

The U.S. Coast Guard is monitoring a 587-foot bulk carrier Ultra Lascar after the ship lost propulsion at 10:20 a.m., approximately five miles offshore from Daly City, Calif.

Maritime Safety

Grounded Bulker Repaired, Heads for Japan

The Captain of the Port for Oregon and southern Washington canceled the captain of the port order on the motor vessel Sparna allowing the vessel to leave its mooring at Kalama, Wash.

Winners of Ferry Design Contest Selected

Winners of International Student Design Competition for a Safe Affordable Ferry to be revealed at the Ferry Safety and Technology Conference   Dr. Roberta Weisbrod,

Maritime Consolidation: Palfinger Aims to Acquire Harding

As maritime markets continue to struggle, merger and acquisition activity should heat up. Today, Austria's Palfinger Group announced that it intends to acquire

Vessels

FIO’s New Research Vessel Enters Build Phase

The 78’ research vessel designed and engineered by Boksa Marine Design (BMD) in 2015 is headed to the building phase beginning in June.   BMD contracted with

HII Secures Aircraft Carrier Planning Contract

Huntington Ingalls Industries (HII) was awarded a $152 million contract for advance planning for the construction of the third aircraft carrier in the Gerald R.

'K' Line Takes Delivery of Corona Series Coal Carrier

Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha, Ltd., Tokyo, (“K” Line) has announced the delivery of Corona Victory, an 88,000 DWT-type special coal carrier at Marugame Shipyard of Imabari Shipbuilding Co.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Contracts Maritime Standards Navigation Offshore Oil Pod Propulsion Ship Electronics Ship Repair Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1309 sec (8 req/sec)