Tankship Market & Return of Contango: Analysis

By George Backwell
Monday, July 21, 2014
Crude carrier: File picture CCL

This week, the Brent price curve moved into contango on what was reported to be short-term physical oversupply. In their latest 'Tanker Opinion', Poten & Partners consider whether this is likely to be a long-lasting change

(“Contango” is a term used to refer to a commodity price structure whereby the spot price is lower than the future price).

The swirl of political events and policy changes over the past few weeks has churned out mixed results for the crude oil markets. At this point it is difficult to characterize the state of the market as anything but flux. The persistence of geopolitical unrest – Ukraine v. Russia, Iraq v. Iraq, and Israel v. Gaza – has supported overall price levels above near-term historical averages. But, crude oil price benchmarks that typically move in tandem, diverged this week.

 Perhaps eclipsing the shaky political climate, infrastructure developments and policy changes have, at least for the short-term, apparently decoupled the US crude oil benchmark, West Texas Intermediate (WTI), and its European counterpart, Brent, in potentially significant ways. While it is too soon to say whether this will be sustained, this development could raise some interesting prospects for the tanker market.

This week, the Brent price curve moved into contango on what was reported to be short-term physical oversupply. “Contango” is a term used to refer to a commodity price structure whereby the spot price is lower than the future price. Typically, oil market price structures are in what is the opposite of contango - “backwardation” – where the spot price is higher than the future price: think; a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

The driver of a transition from backwardation to contango is the sense that the market feels well supplied today (spot), but that it could be undersupplied in the future (forward); hence, the higher relative price. Often, this results from the realization that the market is more adequately supplied than originally thought.

At the time of writing, the Brent contango is relatively small. The premium for both the one-month and two-month forward contract is $1.35 per barrel.

It is interesting to note the pronounced backwardation in early June 2014 and the contango of December 2008. At that time, there was an $8.03 per barrel premium for a 6-month forward contract. At that time, crude oil was also $40.81 per barrel! The steep contango resulted from the near-term price collapse in oil, but the general recognition that prices would recover over time. To the tanker market, these price differentials of $5.00-$8.00 per barrel justified the economics of hiring vessels for floating storage -- lots of them. At one point, between 40-50 VLCCs were reported as floating storage.

When evaluating the use of tankers as floating storage, here are the costs to consider: daily hire of the vessel, carrying cost of holding the oil cargo, insurance, and operating expense or fuel for the ship (depending on the charter arrangement.) It seems unlikely that the nascent, if budding, contango of today, at a mere $1.00 per barrel, could warrant the expense and effort associated with hiring a vessel expressly for floating storage.

Instead, what is likely to happen is that oil companies with barrels on the water might exercise floating storage clauses (which are common in many charter parties) or simply sit the vessel and incur demurrage. If more ships are in storage, key markets, like the Arabian Gulf, could experience shortened tonnage availability in the coming months.

At present, demurrage for a VLCC is assessed to be $40,000 per day. At that rate, an oil company would just about break-even from a freight perspective for a two-month storage charter. However, remember, that kind of math does not consider the other associated carrying costs. Assuming a 10% cost of capital, the monthly carrying costs are approximately $0.89 per barrel on the basis of $106/bbl crude oil – more than double that of 2008. These assumptions suggest that the contango would likely need to deepen to the tune of $3.00+ per barrel in order to incite material storage charter activity.

Poten concludes:
This week’s developments intimate that the WTI benchmark could be moving more toward global parity over time, due to new pipeline infrastructure and the heightened discussions on crude oil exports.

The longer-term knock-on result could be renewed employment for Suezmaxes and Aframaxes shuttling crude oil around the Atlantic Basin.

Source: Poten & Partners

Maritime Reporter January 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

People & Company News

Kongsberg Expands Louisiana Office, Training Facility

Kongsberg Maritime has purchased approximately 5.2 acres for new construction on an 82,980 sq ft office and training facility. Construction on the James Business

HII Acquires Engineering Solutions Division

Huntington Ingalls Industries (HII) has acquired the Engineering Solutions Division of The Columbia Group, a designer and builder of unmanned underwater vehicles

Sjo Resigns from Polarcus Board of Directors

Polarcus Limited announced that Hege Sjo will resign from its board of directors effective February 2, 2015.   Sjo has accepted an appointment as Deputy Director

Tanker Trends

Tohoku Electric's LNG Buy Sets Asian Spot Level

Japanese utility Tohoku Electric has purchased an LNG cargo for delivery in the third week of March at a price in the low $7 per million British thermal unit (mmBtu) range,

Yemen Lifts Force Majeure on LNG Deliveries

Yemen on Friday lifted force majeure on liquefied natural gas (LNG) deliveries from its Balhaf plant, trading sources with knowledge of the matter said. Reuters reported last week that the 6.

German Shipowner Worst Global Dumper -NSP

German shipowner Ernst Komrowski topped the list of the worst global dumpers with 14 end-of-life vessels sold to the beaches, according to a press release from NGO Ship-breaking Platform (NSP).

Finance

Shippers Must Monitor Greek Government Changes

Moore Stephens says shipping must monitor developments in wake of Greek government change   International accountant and shipping adviser Moore Stephens says

Chevron Scraps 2015 Share Repurchase Program

Chevron Corp halted its 2015 share repurchase program on Friday, a move to conserve cash amid tumbling oil prices.   The company's shares extended loses on the news,

Marquette Transportation Reportedly for Sale

Marquette Transportation Company LLC, a U.S. towboat operator, is exploring a sale that could value it at more than $1 billion and has attracted the interest of

Fuels & Lubes

Marquette Transportation Reportedly for Sale

Marquette Transportation Company LLC, a U.S. towboat operator, is exploring a sale that could value it at more than $1 billion and has attracted the interest of

Tohoku Electric's LNG Buy Sets Asian Spot Level

Japanese utility Tohoku Electric has purchased an LNG cargo for delivery in the third week of March at a price in the low $7 per million British thermal unit (mmBtu) range,

Cosco Profits Boosted by Low Fuel Prices

China Cosco Holdings ended 2014 in profitable territory, growing its net earnings by 50 percent to $56 million on the back of cost cuts, improved revenue and lower bunker fuel prices.

Logistics

Congestion is Port of Long Beach’s Toughest Issue

Slangerup’s State of the Port address outlines goals for Energy Island, smarter supply chain   In his first-ever State of the Port address, Port of Long Beach

Shippers Must Monitor Greek Government Changes

Moore Stephens says shipping must monitor developments in wake of Greek government change   International accountant and shipping adviser Moore Stephens says

ISS Palumbo UK Acquires Union Transport

ISS Palumbo UK, part of maritime services provider Inchcape Shipping Services (ISS), has acquired U.K. freight forwarding specialist Union Transport (Newcastle) Ltd.

Consulting

SECNAV Completes Visit to Paraguay

Secretary of the Navy (SECNAV) Ray Mabus completed a visit to Paraguay Jan. 29 during which he met with Republic of Paraguay President Horacio Cartes to discuss

AAL Launches New Operation in Japan

AAL has announced the launch of a new operation in Japan AAL said the move aims to provide services and on-ground operational support directly to customers in the country,

ClassNK Releases Improved "e-Application"

ClassNK announced the release of an improved "e-Application" system. This improvement was planned based on requests from the users. Therefore, firstly we would

 
 
Maritime Contracts Maritime Security Naval Architecture Offshore Oil Pod Propulsion Port Authority Salvage Ship Repair Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.2326 sec (4 req/sec)