Tankship Market & Return of Contango: Analysis

By George Backwell
Monday, July 21, 2014
Crude carrier: File picture CCL

This week, the Brent price curve moved into contango on what was reported to be short-term physical oversupply. In their latest 'Tanker Opinion', Poten & Partners consider whether this is likely to be a long-lasting change

(“Contango” is a term used to refer to a commodity price structure whereby the spot price is lower than the future price).

The swirl of political events and policy changes over the past few weeks has churned out mixed results for the crude oil markets. At this point it is difficult to characterize the state of the market as anything but flux. The persistence of geopolitical unrest – Ukraine v. Russia, Iraq v. Iraq, and Israel v. Gaza – has supported overall price levels above near-term historical averages. But, crude oil price benchmarks that typically move in tandem, diverged this week.

 Perhaps eclipsing the shaky political climate, infrastructure developments and policy changes have, at least for the short-term, apparently decoupled the US crude oil benchmark, West Texas Intermediate (WTI), and its European counterpart, Brent, in potentially significant ways. While it is too soon to say whether this will be sustained, this development could raise some interesting prospects for the tanker market.

This week, the Brent price curve moved into contango on what was reported to be short-term physical oversupply. “Contango” is a term used to refer to a commodity price structure whereby the spot price is lower than the future price. Typically, oil market price structures are in what is the opposite of contango - “backwardation” – where the spot price is higher than the future price: think; a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

The driver of a transition from backwardation to contango is the sense that the market feels well supplied today (spot), but that it could be undersupplied in the future (forward); hence, the higher relative price. Often, this results from the realization that the market is more adequately supplied than originally thought.

At the time of writing, the Brent contango is relatively small. The premium for both the one-month and two-month forward contract is $1.35 per barrel.

It is interesting to note the pronounced backwardation in early June 2014 and the contango of December 2008. At that time, there was an $8.03 per barrel premium for a 6-month forward contract. At that time, crude oil was also $40.81 per barrel! The steep contango resulted from the near-term price collapse in oil, but the general recognition that prices would recover over time. To the tanker market, these price differentials of $5.00-$8.00 per barrel justified the economics of hiring vessels for floating storage -- lots of them. At one point, between 40-50 VLCCs were reported as floating storage.

When evaluating the use of tankers as floating storage, here are the costs to consider: daily hire of the vessel, carrying cost of holding the oil cargo, insurance, and operating expense or fuel for the ship (depending on the charter arrangement.) It seems unlikely that the nascent, if budding, contango of today, at a mere $1.00 per barrel, could warrant the expense and effort associated with hiring a vessel expressly for floating storage.

Instead, what is likely to happen is that oil companies with barrels on the water might exercise floating storage clauses (which are common in many charter parties) or simply sit the vessel and incur demurrage. If more ships are in storage, key markets, like the Arabian Gulf, could experience shortened tonnage availability in the coming months.

At present, demurrage for a VLCC is assessed to be $40,000 per day. At that rate, an oil company would just about break-even from a freight perspective for a two-month storage charter. However, remember, that kind of math does not consider the other associated carrying costs. Assuming a 10% cost of capital, the monthly carrying costs are approximately $0.89 per barrel on the basis of $106/bbl crude oil – more than double that of 2008. These assumptions suggest that the contango would likely need to deepen to the tune of $3.00+ per barrel in order to incite material storage charter activity.

Poten concludes:
This week’s developments intimate that the WTI benchmark could be moving more toward global parity over time, due to new pipeline infrastructure and the heightened discussions on crude oil exports.

The longer-term knock-on result could be renewed employment for Suezmaxes and Aframaxes shuttling crude oil around the Atlantic Basin.

Source: Poten & Partners

Maritime Reporter August 2014 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

People & Company News

Continental Resources Names New President after Bott's Quick Exit

Continental Resources Inc, the largest oil producer in North Dakota's Bakken shale formation, promoted Jack Stark to president on Wednesday, less than a week after Rick Bott quit the position.

Aiming to Make Less Fuel Go Further: Maersk Drilling

Maersk Drilling says it is engaged in an energy efficiency project for its newbuilds together with Maersk Maritime Technology. The project involves an Energy Management System (MSPS),

PierPass' New President Responsible for Ports of LA & Long Beach

New president John Cushing’s role gives him responsibility for PierPass programs to relieve congestion and improve air quality at the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach.

Tanker Trends

For Europe's LNG Ports, Russia Gas Fears and US Exporters Buoy Demand

Gas buyers nervous of Russia cutting supply are helping solve Europe's problem of too many underused liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals, as they seek space at France's Dunkirk plant.

Buckeye Pipeline Quietly Makes Key Acquisition

Houston-based logistic firm Buckeye Partners has spent more than $3.5 billion buying assets since 2010, transforming itself from a quiet regional pipeline utility into an emerging energy powerhouse.

Scorpio Tankers Receive 7 More Newbuildings

Scorpio Tankers Inc. say it has recently taken delivery of seven newbuilding vessels as follows: STI Madison and STI Park, LR2 product tankers, were delivered

Finance

Aiming to Make Less Fuel Go Further: Maersk Drilling

Maersk Drilling says it is engaged in an energy efficiency project for its newbuilds together with Maersk Maritime Technology. The project involves an Energy Management System (MSPS),

Sound Oil Announce 2014 Interim Results

Sound Oil, the European / Mediterranean focused upstream oil and gas company, announced its unaudited interim results for the six months ended 30 June 2014.   Highlights   *

Tax Relief for Indian Seafarers

Indian seafarers serving on Indian flagged vessel are forced to pay income tax if their vessel touches two Indian ports during a voyage whereas Indians serving

Fuels & Lubes

Aiming to Make Less Fuel Go Further: Maersk Drilling

Maersk Drilling says it is engaged in an energy efficiency project for its newbuilds together with Maersk Maritime Technology. The project involves an Energy Management System (MSPS),

Maersk Sees US Approval of Shipping Alliance as Formality

U.S. regulatory approval of a proposed shipping alliance involving AP Moeller Maersk should be a formality, the Danish company's chief executive said on Wednesday.

Buckeye Pipeline Quietly Makes Key Acquisition

Houston-based logistic firm Buckeye Partners has spent more than $3.5 billion buying assets since 2010, transforming itself from a quiet regional pipeline utility into an emerging energy powerhouse.

Logistics

Maersk Sees US Approval of Shipping Alliance as Formality

U.S. regulatory approval of a proposed shipping alliance involving AP Moeller Maersk should be a formality, the Danish company's chief executive said on Wednesday.

Buckeye Pipeline Quietly Makes Key Acquisition

Houston-based logistic firm Buckeye Partners has spent more than $3.5 billion buying assets since 2010, transforming itself from a quiet regional pipeline utility into an emerging energy powerhouse.

CEVA Opens European Center of Logistics Excellence

CEVA Logistics, a leading global supply chain management company, today announced the opening of its first Center of Logistics Excellence in Europe. Situated in Ashby de la Zouch,

Consulting

Ebola & the Shipping Industry: Latest McQuilling Analysis

Although the Ebola epidemic has remained predominantly in West Africa, fears about the virus have spread globally and it is becoming a cause for concern in the transportation industry.

RRI Launch Marine Services J/V with a Trans-Atlantic Reach

Regional Reporting Inc. (RRI) and Global Risk Evaluations (GREvL) inform of the creation of a joint venture aimed at expanding their marine services offerings.

Upcoming Winter Tanker Market Same as Last Year?

Will the 2014/15 winter tanker market be a repeat of the previous one? Poten & Partners consider the question in their latest 'Poten Tanker Opinion'. As the

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Security Maritime Standards Naval Architecture Offshore Oil Pipelines Salvage Ship Simulators Sonar Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1954 sec (5 req/sec)