Charter Party Dispute: Shipowner Acted Unreasonably

MaritimePropulsion.com
Monday, September 09, 2013

In a recent decision, the Commercial Court held that a shipowner's refusal to allow two VLCC's nominated by the charterers to carry out STS transfer operations was unreasonable. The decision was noted by Hattie Sumption, partner at Clyde & Co LLP as follows:

Facts

A vessel was chartered to carry crude from Yemen to the Far East. The charterer also nominated 2 VLCCs to act as storage and receive the cargo at the discharge port by way of STS transfer. The owner of the chartered vessel withheld its approval of the 2 VLCCs and the charterer therefore had to discharge the cargo into smaller vessels to shuttle the cargo into the VLCCs.

Charter Party Terms

The charter party provided that if the charterer required ship-to ship transfer operations, all vessels to be used would be 'subject to the prior approval of owners, which not to be unreasonably withheld...'. It further provided that 'Charterers shall have the option of transferring... cargo... to or from any vessel including, but not limited to, an ocean-going vessel... All transfers... shall be carried out in accordance with the recommendations set out in the latest edition of the 'ICS/OCIMF Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (Petroleum)'.

Judgment


The Court held that the shipowner unreasonably withheld its approval of the 2 nominated VLCCs. On a proper construction of the charter party terms, the shipowner's right of approval was limited to an approval of a nominated vessel by reference to its suitability to the proposed STS operation and did not extend to a right to approve the proposed STS operation itself. In this context, the phrase 'not to be unreasonably withheld' was found to mean that the shipowner which refused approval was not allowed to base its decision on something other than the specific facts of the matter in question. 


The shipowner in this case had a company policy of not allowing STS between VLCCs, as a result of a previous incident. This was not sufficient grounds for a reasonable shipowner to decline approval in the present case. There was nothing inherent in the characteristics of the 2 nominated VLCCs that made a veto of the STS transfers involving them reasonable. Although there was no section in the ICS/OCIMF guide specifically relating to STS between VLCCs, this did not mean that STS operations could not be conducted in accordance with it: with adequate planning and precautions, STS could have been performed in accordance with the guide and therefore in accordance with the charter party.

Comment

The Court examined both the terms of the charter party and the specific facts of the case. Although the facts will vary between each case, the judgment does provide guidance on how the Court is likely to construe similar contentions made by shipowners in future, for example facts relating to the specific operation itself will be deemed to be irrelevant. STS between VLCCs should not be regarded as inherently suspect but should be considered on a case-by-case basis.

Court of Appeal

The decision is being appealed, and a further update will follow after the outcome of the appeal hearing, which has been fixed for early 2014.

Source: UK P&I Club/Hattie Sumption, partner at Clyde & Co LLP
 

Maritime Reporter October 2013 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Contracts

Scanjet Secures 30-ship Tank Management Order

Scanjet Group has followed up its Tank Management order from Stolt-Nielsen with a series of contracts for its ITAMA Intelligent Tank Management concept including Tankcleaning,

Odfjell Finalizes LPG/Ethylene Joint Venture Deal

Following Odfjell SE’s May 16, 2014 announcement declaring the signing of a definitive agreement to form a LPG/E shipping joint venture, Odfjell today announced

Australia, US Order Anti-ship Missile Decoys

Design of the next generation of anti-ship missile decoys is set to commence following the signing of two contracts between the Australian Defense Force and BAE Systems Australia Pty Ltd.

Legal

Port Firm Fined £650,000 for Health, Safety Breach

A port operator has today (Monday 29 September) pleaded guilty to health and safety breaches, following the deaths of three crew members of a tug which capsized on the River Clyde in 2007.

IMO Takes Step Towards Electronic Certificates

In the future, the IMO member States should accept the use of electronic certificates. This is the request of the Facilitation Committee (FAL) and, hence, the road is paved for less paperwork,

K-Line to Plead Guilty to Price Fixing

Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd. (K-Line), a Japanese corporation, has agreed to plead guilty and to pay a $67.7 million criminal fine for its involvement in a conspiracy to fix prices,

Tanker Trends

Scanjet Secures 30-ship Tank Management Order

Scanjet Group has followed up its Tank Management order from Stolt-Nielsen with a series of contracts for its ITAMA Intelligent Tank Management concept including Tankcleaning,

Odfjell Finalizes LPG/Ethylene Joint Venture Deal

Following Odfjell SE’s May 16, 2014 announcement declaring the signing of a definitive agreement to form a LPG/E shipping joint venture, Odfjell today announced

Scanjet Bags Multiple Tank Management Orders

SCANJET Group has followed up its breakthrough Tank Management order from Stolt-Nielsen with a series of contracts for its ITAMA Intelligent Tank Management concept including Tankcleaning,

P&I Clubs

Coast Guard: Investigations Underway in Cutter Collision

The Coast Guard is conducting a series of formal investigations after Tuesday’s collision involving a Coast Guard cutter and a fishing vessel off the coast of Puerto Rico.

The Great Lakes Ballast Water Challenge Explained

Skuld P&I Club in a members advisory explores the regulatory framework and practical issues that exist in both Canada and the USA with input from BLG of Montreal and Chalos & Co of New York.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Naval Architecture Navigation Pipelines Pod Propulsion Port Authority Salvage Ship Electronics Ship Repair Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.3165 sec (3 req/sec)