US Supreme Court Hears Intertanko Oral Argument

Thursday, December 30, 1999
On Dec. 7 the US Supreme Court heard the oral arguments of Intertanko, the US federal government, and the State of Washington in the State of Washington tanker regulations case. The hearing lasted just over one hour, with the Intertanko counsel using 15 minutes, the Justice Department 15 minutes and the lawyer for Washington State 30 minutes. This was followed by questions from the justices and a final summing up, with two minutes allowed to each of the three parties. Intertanko's US legal counsel, Jonathan Benner, reports that the nine Supreme Court justices were well prepared and understood the arguments. The questions put to the Intertanko and the US federal government attorneys were 'reasonable and sought clarification of certain points'. At this stage it is impossible to judge the outcome, but the Intertanko participants at the hearing felt that the merits of the arguments put forward by Intertanko and the US federal government were appreciated by the Supreme Court. The final decision is expected sometime in the six-week period from late March to mid-May 2000. At that point the Supreme Court will issue either a clear decision or a remand in which the case is turned back to the District Court in Seattle with clear instructions on how the Supreme Court justices believe it should be decided. As originally drafted, the Washington State regulations required US and foreign tankers carrying oil in Washington waters to comply with a number of unique requirements governing shipboard equipment and ship operational, management and crewing standards. Intertanko brought suit against these rules in 1995 on the grounds that they were constitutionally invalid due to the existence of similar international and US federal regulations. In June 1998 the Ninth Circuit Court issued a mixed decision, striking down those Washington State rules requiring specific equipment on tankers, such as emergency towing gear, differing from that mandated internationally, but upholding those state rules laying down special ship operational, management and crew training standards. Following the partial success achieved with this decision, the Association decided to press on with its case and to seek a hearing with the highest court in the US, an initiative which proved successful. In its argument before the Supreme Court, Intertanko pointed out that the proliferation of variable local regulations governing vessel safety and environmental protection not only places at risk the validity of the international safety regime but also ultimately jeopardizes the natural environment that Washington State is seeking to protect. The US federal government has supported Intertanko with its legal action at both the Circuit Court and Supreme Court levels. (Source: Intertanko)
Maritime Reporter July 2014 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Legal

Skangass Granted Permission for LNG Terminal

The Swedish Government (Länsstyrelsen in Dalarnas Län) has granted Skangass permission to build and operate a new Terminal for LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) within the harbour in Gävle, Sweden.

Iraq to Appeal US Court Decision on Kurdish Oil

The Iraqi oil ministry said on Thursday it would challenge a U.S. court decision that stopped U.S. Marshals from seizing some one million barrels of disputed Kurdish oil docked near Texas.

USCG Shares Safety Tips for Labor Day, Riverfest

Labor Day weekend marks the unofficial end of the boating season and is known as one of the busiest recreational boating weekends on the Ohio River. With approximately 2,

Marine Electronics

BCG Releases PCVM Emulation

Buffalo Computer Graphics (BCG) Inc. announced the addition of another emulation product to its family of Radar Simulators. BCG has completed an emulation of the VisionMaster FT radar – our PCVM.

Telemar to Supply Broadband for Herm. Dauelsberg

Telemar GmbH, the German subsidiary of the Telemar Group, closed an agreement with Herm. Dauelsberg for the supply of a complete “turn-key solution” for their fleet of 18 vessels.

MN 100: gplink

1500 Sensation Weigh Beaufort, NC 28516 Tel: (252) 504-2640    Email: dwebb@gplink.com Website: www.gplink.com President & CEO: Greg Poole, III The Company: gplink

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Navigation Offshore Oil Pod Propulsion Port Authority Salvage Ship Electronics Ship Repair Ship Simulators Sonar
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | terms and conditions | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1108 sec (9 req/sec)