Commodity Giant Steps out of the Shadows
Thursday, April 17, 2014
Photo: Trafigura

A detailed new case study scrutinizing the risk-management Swiss-based Trafigura is the latest effort to "demystify" the once-secretive commodity trading industry, just big merchants seek to fill a void being left by Wall Street banks.

The study, "The Economics of Commodity Trading Firms," comes as U.S. regulators mull new restrictions on banks' physical commodity trading, a crackdown some large energy companies say would rob them of credit-worthy, transparent counterparties and leave them at the mercy of shadowy and risky firms.

Facing higher capital requirements and regulatory pressure, some banks like JPMorgan Chase & Co have already quit the business of shipping cargoes of crude and storing metal, opening an opportunity for the mostly privately-held trading houses like Trafigura and Mercuria to take up new customers.

"A number of these firms have become very large - too large to ignore, if you like," said Anthony Gowers, global head of corporate affairs at Trafigura, explaining the rationale for the study. "So even those of us who remain private companies feel the need to explain themselves somewhat more in public."

The firm approached Craig Pirrong, a well-known professor of finance and commodity markets commentator at the University of Houston, last July to commission an independent review of the commodity trading industry, with the goal of "demystifying" it.

The resulting 63-page report, based on public filings and interviews with around 10 senior Trafigura traders and a number of C-level executives last September, reached a conclusion similar to several previous reports: relative to Wall Street banks, merchant trading companies' size, function and balance sheets make them far less likely to be sources of systemic risk.

The finding itself is perhaps less surprising than the depth of detail laid out about a company that until last year had never issued a public annual report, in an industry that until the past few years had shunned the public spotlight.

Pirrong has studied commodity markets for 25 years, but said his sojourn in Switzerland provided his first glimpse into a trading firm's "inner sanctum."

"The way they characterized it was that this was sort of our 'coming-out,'" he said. "We haven't had that much of a profile in the past, and we're introducing ourselves."

He used Trafigura, a firm that recorded revenues of $133 billion in 2013 trading everything from oil to iron ore, as a case study to illustrate how trading houses manage the risks of storing, transporting and refining raw materials.

Among his findings: the firm normally has up to $1 billion posted at collateral with clearing houses; about 15 percent of all its trades are uncleared over-the-counter transactions; and it has invested some $550 million over the past three years to build the information technology system to manage its business.

The Dangers of "Shadow Institutions"

The study's central finding was that because commodity trading firms have stronger balance sheets, less leverage and a minimal role in supplying credit to the broader economy, they are not a significant source of systemic risk.

The study comes as the Federal Reserve solicits input for new rules that could pare banks' involvement in the raw materials supply chain over concerns that a catastrophic event could jeopardize the financial system.

In a series of letters, U.S. energy companies warned that pushing banks out of physical commodities will leave them doing business with unregulated entities.

"Recent history is filled with examples of the dangers of unregulated, shadow institutions taking on a large role in the financial system," according to one letter from natural gas industry groups.

Gowers said more transparency could dispel those fears.

"Probably the biggest reason for suspicion is that the industry has historically tended to say 'We're private, mind your own business,' and that's no longer acceptable," he said.

(Reporting by Anna Louie Sussman; Editing by Jonathan Leff and Meredith Mazzilli)

  • Photo: Trafigura

    Photo: Trafigura

Maritime Today

The Maritime Industry's original and most viewed E-News Service

Maritime Reporter November 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

People & Company News

Crowley Opens Government Services Office

Crowley Maritime Corp. has opened a new government services office in downtown Norfolk, Va. to help the company better serve government agencies such as the Military Sealift Command (MSC) and the U.

Interview: Mike Petters - President & CEO, HII

Last month Mike Petters, president and CEO of Huntington Ingalls Industries (NYSE:HII), was honored by the Coast Guard Foundation at the 35th Annual Salute to the United States Coast Guard,

McAllister Towing – 150 Years of Family Business

“Early in 1864, a young man names James McAllister stood on board a sailing vessel where he served as a mate. The boat was about to set sail from the Red Bay of


When Conducting Investigations Consider 'Privileges'

Whether voluntarily or as required by the International Safety Management Code, the American Waterways Operators’ (AWO) Responsible Carrier Program, or some other rule or regulation,

Deepwater Downturn: Bump in the Road or Long-Term Slowing of Growth?

IMA/World Energy Reports has just completed a comprehensiveassessment of the five year outlook for the deepwater sector.  The new report – the 19th annual floater

North Group Increases Projected Free Reserve

Directors of the North P&I Club and Sunderland Marine Insurance Company (North Group) have revised their projection for the group’s year-end free reserve up to $380 million,


Tidal Energy from Deep and Slow Waters

Deep Green, an underwater kite construction from the Swedish company Minesto, is set to be deployed in 2017 at the Holyhead Deep site off the coast of Anglesey, Wales.

Philippines Takes South China Sea Claim to Hague

Could bolster claims by other countries against China; China boycotting proceedings, rejects court's authority. The Philippines asked global judges on Tuesday

Fredriksen's Firms See Diverging Fortunes

Rig firm Seadrill sees tough market continuing in 2016. Firms in Norwegian-born billionaire John Fredriksen's empire saw contrasting fortunes on Tuesday, as rig firm Seadrill booked $1.


Fincantieri Launches Nuclear Waste Vessel for Russia

New semisubmersible floating platform will be used to transport special material decommissioned by the Russian Navy    Itarus, the new semisubmersible floating

Port of Bronka Prepares for Opening

Technical plant and equipment installation for the first stage of Bronka’s port facilities is now complete with the Liebherr LHM 800 mobile port crane installed at the end of September,

Vesper Marine Debuts New AIS Transponder

Marine safety products manufacturer Vesper Marine has released a new Class B Automatic Identification System (AIS), the XB-6000. The black box transponder includes

Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Contracts Naval Architecture Navigation Pod Propulsion Salvage Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction Sonar Winch
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.1742 sec (6 req/sec)