Transocean in U.S. Federal Court on BP Obligations

press release
Tuesday, November 01, 2011

Transocean Files Motion for Summary Judgment in U.S. Federal Court to Compel BP to Honor Its Contractual Indemnity Obligations

 

Transocean Offshore Deepwater Drilling Inc. (TODDI), a subsidiary of Transocean Ltd., today filed a motion for summary judgment in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana requesting the court to compel BP to honor its contractual obligation to defend, indemnify and hold harmless Transocean for damages associated with BP's failure to contain flow from its Macondo well in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.

 

The contract between BP and Transocean for the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig contains industry-standard reciprocal indemnity provisions that apportion risk and quantify liabilities between the two companies. In the contract, which was signed in 1998 and extended several times including in 2009, BP agreed to "defend, release, protect, indemnify and hold harmless" Transocean for any and all fines, penalties and damages associated with environmental pollution originating from the well "without limit and without regard to the cause or causes" including negligence, "whether such negligence be sole, joint, active passive or gross."

 

Despite these clear and unambiguous terms, BP has refused to honor its contractual obligations to Transocean stemming from the Macondo well incident in April of 2010. In fact, contrary to its promise to "defend" and "indemnify" Transocean, BP instead filed suit against Transocean on the one-year anniversary of the incident, alleging that Transocean personnel -- including those who lost their lives in the incident -- had willful and callous disregard for the welfare of their colleagues and the environment. Transocean has honored its contractual indemnity obligations to BP nonetheless.

 

"BP's posture in this matter is not only offensive to the thousands of men and women who work together at Transocean, but it constitutes a direct threat to the sanctity of contracts and to the economic underpinnings of an industry that employs hundreds of thousands of people in the United States alone," said Nick Deeming, Senior Vice President and General Counsel of Transocean. "This motion is about more than just two companies," Deeming continued. "It is about the future of the contract drilling industry at large. If BP truly intends to make things right, it must either voluntarily or by the order of the court honor all of its contracts - not just the ones that serve its convenience or financial purposes."

 

According to the filed motion, BP has cited "ongoing investigations" and BP's own "allegations" of gross negligence on the part of Transocean as justification for BP's refusal to honor its contractual promises. The motion also asserts that after months of discovery and more than 200 witness depositions, it is clear that no evidence of gross negligence by Transocean exists. In fact, as outlined in the motion, BP oversaw, audited and commended the Deepwater Horizon rig and her crew before the incident, and every BP witness deposed as part of the litigation in New Orleans has stated under oath that the rig was fit for purpose and was operated by a safety-conscious crew.

 

Key excerpts from the brief -- which is available online at www.deepwater.com -- are as follow:

-- Transocean respectfully requests that the Court require BP to honor its contractual promises. Transocean requests that its motion for partial summary judgment be granted, specifically that:

-- The express indemnity promises made by BP in the Drilling Contract override any alleged rights of BP to contribution;

-- The indemnity provisions agreed to by BP in the Drilling Contract are valid and enforceable against the OPA statutory backdrop, including indemnity for the uncapped liability that arises upon a finding that an incident resulted from gross negligence;

-- BP's contribution claims are barred by BP's contractual promise to defend Transocean, and BP must defend Transocean against environmental wellhead pollution claims pending against it that arise from the Macondo blowout;

-- BP cannot avoid its contractual promise by alleging that Transocean breached the Drilling Contract or that the Deepwater Horizon was unseaworthy;

-- BP cannot avoid its contractual promise by alleging that Transocean or its employees were grossly negligent;

-- BP is required to honor its promise to indemnify Transocean for Clean Water Act (CWA) and any other civil penalties;

-- BP is required to honor its promise to pay the unpaid charter hire for the Deepwater Horizon;

-- As a result of BP's failure to honor its promises in each of the above areas, BP be required to reimburse Transocean its attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses incurred in defending environmental claims for which BP is contractually obligated and those incurred in forcing BP to honor its contractual promises.

To read the Deepwater Horizon contract with BP, see the company's 10-Q Quarterly Report for the Second Quarter 2010 dated August 4, 2010 or at: http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1451505/000145150510000069/exhibit10_1.pdf

Maritime Reporter August 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

People & Company News

Odfjell Reports Best Quarter Since 2008

In what it is calling its best quarterly performance since third quarter 2008, the Odfjell Group for the second quarter of 2015 reported net results of $7 million.

Great Lakes Shipyard to Build Guatemalan Harbor Tug

U.S. shipbuilding and repair yard Great Lakes Shipyard informs it has signed a contract to build another of its HandySize Class, 3,400 HP twin-screw tugboat for

BAE Systems Welcomes Record Number of Paid Interns

More than 140 university students from across the country are being given a unique insight into working life at BAE Systems, as part of the company’s 12-week summer internship program.

Legal

DP World H1 Earnings Jump, Mulls Iran launch

DP World may launch operations in Iran, the company's chairman said on Thursday, as the global ports operator reported a jump in half-year earnings after buying assets from its parent company.

IMEI Certification - Unique Achievement

For Institute of Marine Engineers of India having achieved standardisation and maintainenace of quality processes simultaneously not just at their Head Office

Wärtsilä 34DF Becoming a Trendsetter

The upgraded version of the Wärtsilä 34DF engine is rapidly becoming established as an industry standard. The three major South Korean shipyards are supporting

Energy

Oil Soars in Biggest One-day Rally in Years

Oil rocketed as much as 10 percent higher on Thursday, posting its biggest one-day rally since 2009 as recovering equity markets and news of diminished crude supplies

Odfjell Reports Best Quarter Since 2008

In what it is calling its best quarterly performance since third quarter 2008, the Odfjell Group for the second quarter of 2015 reported net results of $7 million.

Drydocks World World’s Largest Turret

Drydocks World marked a milestone in completing the world’s largest turret mooring system. At almost 100 meters high, weighing over 11,000 tons and with a diameter of 26 meters,

News

Oil Soars in Biggest One-day Rally in Years

Oil rocketed as much as 10 percent higher on Thursday, posting its biggest one-day rally since 2009 as recovering equity markets and news of diminished crude supplies

Odfjell Reports Best Quarter Since 2008

In what it is calling its best quarterly performance since third quarter 2008, the Odfjell Group for the second quarter of 2015 reported net results of $7 million.

Fisherman Hit by Parted Line Lifted to Safety

A fisherman struck and injured by a parted line was medevaced south of San Juan Island and transported to Olympic Medical Center in Port Angeles, Wash. Thursday morning.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Security Maritime Standards Navigation Port Authority Salvage Ship Electronics Ship Repair Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction Sonar
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.8951 sec (1 req/sec)