Krepp Comments on GSA Storis Auction

marinelink.com
Wednesday, March 12, 2014
Denise Krepp

Denise Rucker Krepp, former Maritime Administration Chief Counsel who currently advocates on behalf of the U.S. domestic ship recycling industry, issued a statement at the Coast Guard Shipping Coordinating Committee Meeting March 12, 2014, in Preparation for the April 2014 Maritime Environment Protection Committee Meeting. Below are her comments.

Good morning. My name is Denise Krepp and I am representing EMR-Southern Recycling.

As I mentioned last year, EMR-Southern Recycling is the premier metal recycling operation in the U.S. Gulf Coast region and the largest volume marine ferrous producer in the United States. The company was established in 1900 and currently employs over 600 individuals in Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama and Florida. These hard working, highly skilled men and women, many of whom spend their entire careers with the company, earn good salaries with benefit packages including health insurance and a company 401k match. Other domestic competitors to EMR’s marine ferrous operations, which include SIMs Metals ESCO facility and Scrap Metal Services All-Star facility, directly and indirectly employ several thousand more.

At last year's public meeting, I asked for assistance from the U.S. government. I requested a meeting with the Coast Guard, Environmental Protection Agency, Maritime Administration (MARAD), and State Department officials and other ship scrapping company representatives to discuss the U.S. government's position on the Hong Kong Ship Recycling Convention. EMR-Southern Recycling wanted to learn whether or not the U.S. government supported this treaty and how the government was going to implement it domestically. The Administration was non-responsive.

In addition, I stated at last year's public meeting that EMR-Southern Recycling wanted to work with the U.S. government to ensure that U.S. built ships are recycled in the United States instead of being reflagged for foreign dismantlement. Foreign recycling facilities are not held to the same high and necessary standards as those in the United States. Our ships should be taken apart in the same careful and protected manner as when they were put together.

The Administration declined Southern Recycling's offer. Instead, the Administration allowed the General Services Administration (GSA) to auction on June 27, 2013, the historic Coast Guard cutter Storis, which had been laid up at the Suisun Bay Reserve Fleet (SBRF). The winning bid was little over $70,000 and GSA approved this bid even though it was less than the reserve price. (See http://gsaauctions.gov/gsaauctions/aucdsclnk?sl=41QSCI13425001)

After winning the auction, the new buyer tried to resell the Storis for $250,000 to national preservationists while the vessel sat for months in the SBRF. (See http://www.timesheraldonline.com/news/ci_24432274/will-historic-coast-guard-ship-escape-scrap-heap). When the national preservationists refused to pay the buyer's exorbitant asking price, the buyer sent the Storis to Mexico to be scrapped.

The scrapping of the Storis in Mexico violates Section 3502 of the 2009 Duncan Hunter National Defense Authorization Act which requires all U.S. government vessels to be scrapped at U.S. metal recycling facilities. (See http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/PLAW-110publ417/pdf/PLAW-110publ417.pdf). The GSA sale also violates 40 U.S.C. 548 which mandates that MARAD be responsible for disposing of vessels greater than 1500 gross tons. (See http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2011-title40/pdf/USCODE-2011-title40-subtitleI-chap5-subchapIII-sec548.pdf). The Storis was over 2000 gross tons and it should have been auctioned off by MARAD to domestic ship recyclers.

Several individuals have FOIAed the government for information on the Storis' debacle, as well as copies of Memorandums MARAD has with the Coast Guard, Navy, GSA, and other federal agencies concerning the disposal of obsolete vessels. GSA charged one individual almost $10,000 for the GSA files on the Storis auction. MARAD charged another individual over $400 for a five-page 1998 Inter-Agency memorandum that is publicly posted on the web. According to the government, it wasn't in the U.S. taxpayer's interest to release this information for free. Both charges have been appealed.

At last year's meeting I also requested that the Coast Guard publish meeting notes associated with all IMO Shipping Coordinating Committee meetings on its website. I posited that publishing the meeting notes would help improve the transparency of the process. The Coast Guard didn't publish the meeting notes and there is no reference to my earlier comments on the Coast Guard website.

The Coast Guard's refusal to publish the meeting notes on its website violates the President's 2009 and 2014 good government directives. (http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/TransparencyandOpenGovernment and http://m.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ostp/open_gov_plan_guidance_memo_final.pdf). In these documents, the President directs agencies to detail plans by which they are proactively disclosing information to advance transparency, accountability, and the presumption of openess. Refusing to publish meeting notes impedes transparency and creates the perception that the government has something to hide.

The lack of transparency is further compounded by the U.S. government's refusal to communicate with U.S. metal recycling companies on IMO related matters. EMR-Southern Recycling had repeatedly notified the U.S. government over the past year that it wanted to provide input on implementation of the Hong Kong Convention. The U.S. government never responded to EMR-Southern Recycling's request. Instead, the U.S. government communicated solely with foreign governments leaving U.S. companies completely in the dark.

The U.S. government isn't looking out for the interests of the U.S. industry – it's trying to bypass the domestic recycling and steel production industry and scrap vessels abroad. The White House website continues to reference a plan which the MARAD Ship Disposal Program developed in 2006. See http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/assets/omb/expectmore/detail/10004010.2006.html.

According to the MARAD, “(t)he ship disposal program must balance concerns about safety and environment, a growing inventory of aging vessels, and the lack of suitable ship recycling facilities.” (See http://www.marad.dot.gov/documents/Ship_Disposal.pdf) These claims are false. The U.S. ship recycling industry is the safest and most environmentally rigorous in the world. There are currently five qualified companies and at least 11 qualified slips at the disposal of the federal government agencies; and there are new facilities awaiting qualification. These facilities should be fully utilized instead of being ignored.

Therefore, I ask again that the U.S. Executive Branch agencies meet with the domestic ship recycling industry to discuss domestic implementation of the Hong Kong Convention. I also request that the U.S. government work with the domestic ship recycling industry to prevent U.S. vessels from being scrapped in foreign facilities that are not held to the same standards as their U.S. counterparts. Lastly, I ask that the U.S. government publish the meeting notes for all IMO Shipping Coordinating Committee meetings on its website.

I am making these requests on behalf of EMR-Southern Recycling's over 600 employees. These taxpayers provide a valuable service to the U.S. government. Their efforts should be supported not undercut by those who would rather ship their jobs overseas.

About the Speaker: Krepp began her career as an active duty Coast Guard officer in 1998. After September 11, 2001, Krepp helped create the Transportation Security Administration. She also served as Senior Counsel on the House of Representatives Homeland Security Committee. Krepp is a professor at Pennsylvania State University, a member of the Board of Directors for The Infrastructure Security Partnership, and a commentator on Backroom Politics, a weekly radio show.
 

Maritime Reporter July 2015 Digital Edition
FREE Maritime Reporter Subscription
Latest Maritime News    rss feeds

Legal

Missing Person Rescued Near Brackettville

On July 31, Border Patrol Search Trauma and Rescue (BORSTAR) agents and CBP Office of Air and Marine rescued a man who was reported missing the previous morning.

Ross is Fleet Manager, Heidmar

Heidmar announced the promotion of Duncan Ross to Fleet Manager. Duncan joined Heidmar’s London office in 2012 as vessel manager.  Prior to joining Heidmar,

LR First to Certify Small Caribbean Ships

LR is the first class society to certify small commercial ships operating in the Caribbean After becoming the first classification society to issue Cargo

Ship Sales

Fratelli Neri Orders Damen Tug

One of the largest Italian tug owners, Fratelli Neri S.p.A, ordered its first Damen tug, an ASD 3212, on 21 July 2015.   The vessel will be the first ASD tug

China Shipping Orders Eight 13500 TEU Box Ships

China Shipping Container Lines has placed orders for eight 13,500 twenty-foot-equivalent container ships at Shanghai Jiangnan Changxing Shipbuilding, continuing

Pacific Basin Returns to The Black

Pacific Basin Shipping cut its half-year underlying losses by 32 per cent to US$14.6 million from a year ago, thanks to stringent cost-cutting efforts that helped

Environmental

Fire Aboard USS Mount Whitney

A fire broke out on board USS Mount Whitney (LCC 20) while the ship was in Viktor Lenac Shipyard (Rijeka, Croatia) July 31, 2015. There were no personnel injuries in the fire,

USCG Investigate Tar Balls at Makaha Beach

The Coast Guard is investigating a report made July 29, 2015, by beachgoers of tar balls on the beach in Makaha on Oahu, Hawaii. Coast Guard Sector Honolulu

On USCG Anniversary, Gov. McAuliffe Urges Hurricane Preparedness

Gov. Terry McAuliffe encouraged Virginians to get ready for hurricane season and provided an update on the commonwealth’s preparations Friday at a press conference

News

Missing Person Rescued Near Brackettville

On July 31, Border Patrol Search Trauma and Rescue (BORSTAR) agents and CBP Office of Air and Marine rescued a man who was reported missing the previous morning.

Ross is Fleet Manager, Heidmar

Heidmar announced the promotion of Duncan Ross to Fleet Manager. Duncan joined Heidmar’s London office in 2012 as vessel manager.  Prior to joining Heidmar,

Fire Aboard USS Mount Whitney

A fire broke out on board USS Mount Whitney (LCC 20) while the ship was in Viktor Lenac Shipyard (Rijeka, Croatia) July 31, 2015. There were no personnel injuries in the fire,

Coast Guard

USCG Investigate Tar Balls at Makaha Beach

The Coast Guard is investigating a report made July 29, 2015, by beachgoers of tar balls on the beach in Makaha on Oahu, Hawaii. Coast Guard Sector Honolulu

On USCG Anniversary, Gov. McAuliffe Urges Hurricane Preparedness

Gov. Terry McAuliffe encouraged Virginians to get ready for hurricane season and provided an update on the commonwealth’s preparations Friday at a press conference

DHS, Postal Service to Dedicate USCG Forever Stamp

U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Postal Service leaders are scheduled to dedicate the United States Coast Guard Forever stamp during a ceremony Tuesday at Coast Guard Headquarters.

People in the News

USCG Investigate Tar Balls at Makaha Beach

The Coast Guard is investigating a report made July 29, 2015, by beachgoers of tar balls on the beach in Makaha on Oahu, Hawaii. Coast Guard Sector Honolulu

DHS, Postal Service to Dedicate USCG Forever Stamp

U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Postal Service leaders are scheduled to dedicate the United States Coast Guard Forever stamp during a ceremony Tuesday at Coast Guard Headquarters.

South China Sea Hotline in the Works

China and Southeast Asian nations have agreed to set up a foreign ministers' hotline to tackle emergencies in the disputed South China Sea, a senior official of

Government Update

Missing Person Rescued Near Brackettville

On July 31, Border Patrol Search Trauma and Rescue (BORSTAR) agents and CBP Office of Air and Marine rescued a man who was reported missing the previous morning.

Fire Aboard USS Mount Whitney

A fire broke out on board USS Mount Whitney (LCC 20) while the ship was in Viktor Lenac Shipyard (Rijeka, Croatia) July 31, 2015. There were no personnel injuries in the fire,

Thordon Bearings Secures AK Ferry Contract

Thordon Bearings has received an order to supply its COMPAC system to two Alaska Ferry newbuilds under construction at the Vigor Industrial shipyard in Ketchikan, Alaska.

 
 
Maritime Careers / Shipboard Positions Maritime Contracts Maritime Standards Naval Architecture Navigation Pipelines Pod Propulsion Ship Electronics Ship Simulators Shipbuilding / Vessel Construction
rss | archive | history | articles | privacy | contributors | top maritime news | about us | copyright | maritime magazines
maritime security news | shipbuilding news | maritime industry | shipping news | maritime reporting | workboats news | ship design | maritime business

Time taken: 0.2430 sec (4 req/sec)