Judge Dismisses Cruise Passengers' COVID-19 Lawsuits

Maritime Activity Reports, Inc.

July 15, 2020

Grand Princess docks in Oakland (Photo: Port of Oakland)

Grand Princess docks in Oakland (Photo: Port of Oakland)

A federal judge dismissed lawsuits by Grand Princess cruise ship passengers who sued for emotional distress caused by their fear of exposure to COVID-19, saying that allowing their cases to proceed would “lead to a flood of trivial suits.”

Judge Gary Klausner in Los Angeles said in Tuesday’s ruling that allowing passengers to collect damages based on potential COVID-19 exposure without suffering symptoms raised concerns of unlimited liability for restaurants, bars and other places people gather.

Debi Chalik, a lawyer for Ronald and Eva Weissberger of Florida, who filed the first lawsuit against Princess, said she was disappointed with the ruling and was considering an appeal.

Chalik also disagreed that her case would cause a wave of lawsuits because few businesses welcome customers the way Princess did when it knew the virus was potentially present on its ship.

“If a gym or restaurant is inviting people to come when they know the virus is circulating there, I think you should be able to sue those businesses,” she said.

Carnival Corp, which operates the Grand Princess, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The Grand Princess grabbed headlines in March when the ship and its 2,400 passengers were denied entry to San Francisco after an outbreak of the novel coronavirus on the ocean liner.

Nearly a week later, officials arranged for the ship to dock in Oakland, Calif., and passengers were taken into quarantine.

The Weissbergers filed one of the first U.S. lawsuits tied to the pandemic and alleged the cruise line allowed them to board the ship even though passengers who disembarked the same day from a prior cruise had symptoms of COVID-19.

The couple sued for more than $1 million for putting their health at risk and causing them trauma.


(Reporting by Tom Hals; Editing by Richard Chang)

Maritime Reporter E-News subscription

Maritime Reporter E-News is the maritime industry's largest circulation and most authoritative ENews Service, delivered to your Email five times per week

Subscribe for Maritime Reporter E-News